Post Author
David Gaul
Shelby County Democratic Party Co-Chair


Authors  Contributors

David Gaul
Donna Clothier
Kathleen Cue

REBUTTING A REPUBLICAN

As Seen in the Harlan News-Advertiser October 19th, 2012

Jim Bieker’s tirade against President Obama in his letter last week in the News-Advertiser was nothing more than a regurgitation of the same tired, anti-Obama rhetoric we’ve been hearing now for four years, rhetoric backed up with no proof or hard data.

Let’s start with the one that he started with and which has been a favorite for Obama dissenters for a long time.  Using Mr. Bieker’s own words, “Gas was under $2.00 a gallon when Obama took office, and now it’s almost $4.00.”  Mr. Bieker has forgotten that the average price of gasoline reached $4.12 in July of 2008 when George W. Bush was President, but the more important fact he left out was the collapsing U.S. economy that greeted the President the day he took office. 

Yes, gasoline prices were low that day, but so was the stock market.  The Dow that day closed at 7949.  Gasoline prices that day were a reflection of the abysmal economy Obama had inherited on day one.  When economies shut down, energy prices—particularly those intimately connected with commerce—tend to fall.  Ignoring context, when trying to score cheap political points, is disingenuous.

Mr. Bieker did this again when he wrote, “During his time in office, Obama stopped all off shore oil drilling for a season and allowed no new drilling permits.”  Does he really think all of us have forgotten the BP oil drilling disaster of 2010, the worst such disaster in history? 

Eleven rig workers died.  4.9 million barrels of oil leaked into the Gulf of Mexico.  The National Commission on the disaster concluded, “The “blowout was the product of several individual missteps and oversights by BP, Halliburton, and Transocean, which government regulators lacked the authority, the necessary resources, and the technical expertise to prevent.”  Obama did what any responsible leader would have done.  He temporarily shut down similar operations.  He got the facts.  Corrective action was taken.

Mr. Bieker decries the government’s rescue of General Motors and the introduction of the Chevy Volt.  He writes, “Electricity is made from coal!  Obama closed down five coal plants in Pennsylvania.  So what are these cars supposed to run on???” 

Actually, for the year to date, 36% of our electricity has come from coal, and 31% has come from natural gas, according to the U.S. Energy Information Administration.  The coal industry is being pressured by historic low prices for natural gas.  Market forces.  Hydraulic fracturing techniques are creating an abundant supply of natural gas that burns cleaner than coal and more efficiently. 

Those coal-fired power plants in Pennsylvania are being closed by their parent company, GenOn Energy Inc—not Obama.  They’re older, less efficient plants. The one in Portland, Pennsylvania, was the subject of a New Jersey lawsuit in 2007 that claimed the power plant was sending excessive pollution into New Jersey.  The EPA came down hard on this plant, and Chris Christie, New Jersey’s conservative governor, and his administration have applauded this action by the EPA saying in a press release, “It is a priority of the Christie Administration to improve air quality.  We support the EPA in this challenge for the benefit of air quality in New Jersey and for the health of our residents.”

Mr. Bieker ripped the President over the Keystone Pipeline, a pipeline for carrying bitumen Canadian tar sands crude oil—not North Dakota shale oil—to the Gulf coast for refining and world export.  He didn’t mention that Nebraska ranchers and their governor opposed the pipeline initially; concerned about danger it posed to the Ogallala Aquifer.   His assertion that there “has never” been a leak in a Keystone pipeline is wrong.  21.000 gallons of heavy, bitumen crude leaked out of a Keystone pipeline in North Dakota, on May 7th, 2011—one of twelve leaks in all.  Bitumen crude sinks in water.  A leak in a Canadian pipeline in Kalamazoo, Michigan, leaked 800,000 gallons of bitumen crude into the Kalamazoo River in July of 2010. 
  
Four years ago this country teetered on the brink of economic collapse.  The auto industry was about to wind up on the scrap heap.  We were fighting two wars.  Osama bin Laden—murderer of thousands of Americans--was still lurking out there.  We were shedding upwards to 700,000 jobs a month.  The stock market had lost nearly half its value, taking with it the value of many of the retirement accounts of Americans.  Nothing was certain as President Obama took office. 

Now, with the exception of the war in Afghanistan, those dire conditions no longer exist.  Obama’s policies saved the economy and turned things around.  We’ve had thirty-one months of job growth with low inflation.  The farm economy is booming.   Obama is a champion of wind energy and bio-fuels—important issues for Iowans.  We are moving in the right direction, despite historic, unprecedented opposition by Republicans in Congress.  These same Republicans complain that the recovery is too slow.  They should know because their intransigence helped to slow it down, but I would remind them and everyone else that slow and steady wins the race.




RSS Feed Link


Tags:  

Comments Policy Comment Policy
Comments Policy Close

Comments should be viewed as a conversation between two people. Please consider this an interactive discussion and act civilly.

All comments will be approved by a moderator. Although we would like to post every comment submitted immediately, site safety and our family friendly theme does not allow it.

Comments considered or deemed to be obscene, vulgar, cruel, pointless, embarrassing or harmful to this site, in poor taste, accusatory, flames, personal attacks, duplicates or spam will be edited or deleted.

This site is the final arbiter of whether or not a post falls in to one of the above categories. Whether or not a post or comment is displayed will be at our sole discretion and will not be limited by the previous description(s).

Please do not repeat posts, post comments under another persons name or post comments under multiple names. Any of these may cause you to be banned from future posts.

A valid email address is required to post comments, they will not be publicly displayed, published, shared or sold to a third party. Your email address may be used by the moderator to contact you privately.

Please avoid offensive, crude or innapropriate words, terms and descriptions in your comments, this blog intends to be family friendly.

Please do not post comments that detract from the general theme of the blog post and other comments, these can disrupt the "flow" of discussion and may not be approved.

The individual or organization authoring a given blog post may or may not be available to respond to your comments.
The moderator may or may not forward comments to the blog author.
The blog Author may add a response to the blog comments, reply to comments by email or may not be available to respond at all.
Please do not be offended if there is no response to a blog comment, all posted comments should add to the general discussion and not focus on personal questions. Personal questions should be directed to the blog author or you may use our contact form to contact the moderator directly.

Any and all comments posted to this blog are the sole responsibility of the person posting the comments. The blog owner, moderator, author or administrator are responsible for their own posts and comments and cannot be held liable for others comments.

When submitting a comment on this blog, you agree that any comments and content is your own, and to hold this site, and any representatives harmless from any and all repercussions, damages, or liability.

Please refrain from posting personal or private information such as your email, real address, phone number etc., this type of information may be removed from a comment or the comment may not be approved for display. For your protection, never share this type of information in  a comment.

If you feel copyrighted material has been used in a comment or blog post on this blog please use our contact form to notify us and we will  review the information then respond by removing the material in question, responding in a timely fashion or both. We respect the rights of others and will not knowingly display material copyrighted by others.

All blog posts are Copyright of this site or the respective Authors.
Copyright © 2012- 2017  Shelby County Democratic Party  All rights reserved.
Close

Comments Unlocked Comments Email address will not be displayed


User Name: Robert Mortenson   Date: 10/23/12

I think that the harness shops are still busy without the horse cavalry. They are churning out "reality" blinders for the GOP.




Comment:Email address will not be displayed
*Name: 
*Email: 
Website:  Format:http;//www.sitename.com
Comment:
*Enter Verification Code: 64967

* Required
All comments will be reviewed before being displayed. See the comment policy on the right side panel.